As an insurance advisor, I often hear this question from worried clients who’ve accidentally damaged their vehicles.
Yes, you can claim insurance for damage to your own car if you have collision coverage, which covers accidents regardless of fault, or comprehensive coverage for non-collision incidents. However, you’ll need to pay your deductible.
Let me guide you through the important considerations when deciding whether to file a claim.
Does Your Insurance Go Up If You Damage Your Own Car?
I’ve seen many clients struggle with this decision – filing a claim versus paying out of pocket.
Yes, your insurance rates will likely increase after filing a claim for damage you caused, even if no other vehicle was involved. The increase typically lasts 3-5 years and can range from 20% to 40%.
Let’s examine the factors affecting your premium after a claim:
Rate Increase Factors
-
Claim Impact Variables
- Claim amount
- Prior claims history
- Years claim-free
- Policy type
- Coverage levels
- State regulations
- Insurance company
- Accident severity
-
Long-term Effects
- Premium increases
- Loss of discounts
- Policy renewal impact
- Insurance score
- Future insurability
- Coverage restrictions
- Deductible options
- Payment plans
Premium Impact Analysis
| Factor | Duration | Severity |
|---|---|---|
| First Claim | 3 years | Moderate |
| Multiple Claims | 5+ years | Significant |
| Severe Damage | 3-5 years | High |
How Much Will My Insurance Go Up After A Claim?
Through years of analyzing post-claim premium changes, I can provide insight into typical increases.
Insurance rates typically increase 20-40% after a claim, which could mean $400-800 annually on a $2,000 premium. Multiple claims can lead to even higher increases or non-renewal of your policy.
Let’s break down the financial impact:
Cost Impact Analysis
-
Direct Costs
- Premium increase
- Deductible payment
- Loss of discounts
- Policy fees
- Coverage adjustments
- Payment changes
- Administrative fees
- Documentation costs
-
Hidden Expenses
- Future insurability
- Market restrictions
- Coverage limitations
- Premium financing
- Insurance score
- Shopping options
- Policy flexibility
- Renewal terms
Financial Impact Matrix
| Claim Size | Rate Increase | 3-Year Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Minor | 20-25% | $1,200+ |
| Moderate | 25-35% | $2,100+ |
| Major | 35-40%+ | $3,000+ |
Can I Claim Insurance For My Own Damage?
Based on numerous client consultations, I understand the complexity of this decision.
Yes, you can claim insurance for damage you caused if you have collision coverage. However, consider the claim amount versus your deductible and potential premium increases before filing.
Let’s analyze when to file a claim:
Claim Decision Factors
-
Financial Considerations
- Repair costs
- Deductible amount
- Premium impact
- Savings available
- Financing options
- Budget constraints
- Long-term costs
- Alternative solutions
-
Policy Implications
- Coverage limits
- Claim history
- Policy status
- Renewal timing
- Company guidelines
- State regulations
- Documentation
- Reporting requirements
Decision Matrix
| Damage Cost | Deductible | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| Under $1,000 | $500 | Pay out of pocket |
| $1,000-$2,000 | $500 | Consider carefully |
| Over $2,000 | $500 | File claim |
Can I Claim Insurance If I Scratch My Own Car?
Drawing from my experience with minor damage claims[^1], this is a common dilemma.
While you can claim insurance for scratches under collision coverage, it’s often not financially wise. The deductible and potential premium increase usually exceed the repair cost for minor scratches.
Let’s explore the options for minor damage:
Minor Damage Solutions
-
Repair Options
- DIY fixes
- Touch-up paint
- Mobile repair
- Body shops
- Dealer service
- Paint specialists
- Dent removal
- Scratch repair
-
Cost Comparison
- Insurance claim
- Out-of-pocket
- Payment plans
- Shop warranties
- Service packages
- Bundled repairs
- Quality levels
- Time investment
Cost Analysis
| Repair Type | Average Cost | Claim Worth It? |
|---|---|---|
| Light Scratch | $150-300 | No |
| Deep Scratch | $300-800 | Maybe |
| Multiple Areas | $800+ | Consider |
Conclusion
While you can claim insurance for self-inflicted damage, carefully weigh repair costs[^2] against your deductible and potential premium increases[^3]. Often, paying out of pocket for minor damage is more economical long-term.
---
[^1]: Discover the nuances of minor damage claims and when they are worth filing.
[^2]: Get insights into repair costs to better evaluate your insurance options.
[^3]: Learn how premium increases can affect your finances after filing a claim.
